HOLIDAY PAY: WHY THE COUNCIL CAN’T PASS THE BUCK

HOLIDAY PAY: WHY THE COUNCIL CAN’T PASS THE BUCK
For more than ten years, Barnet Council staff who regularly worked overtime were underpaid when they took holiday. While Capita ran the council’s payroll, from 2013 to March 2025, regular overtime was left out of holiday pay. When Liberata took over running payroll in April 2025, on the council’s new Oracle system, it was put right straight away (https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/ieDecisionDetails.aspx?ID=9343.
Capita says it “delivered the service as instructed by Barnet Council” (https://barnetpost.co.uk/2026/08/12/council-leader-to-underpaid-workers-youll-only-get-your-money-by-taking-it-from-disabled-children/). The council has offered staff 18 months of back pay for a 12-year underpayment. Here is why we say the responsibility sits with the council, using its own committee papers.
THE LAW HAS BEEN CLEAR SINCE 2014
In November 2014, in Bear Scotland v Fulton, the Employment Appeal Tribunal ruled that regular overtime must count towards holiday pay. In 2017, Dudley Council v Willetts confirmed this includes regular voluntary overtime. In 2024 the government wrote it into the Working Time Regulations (https://knowledge.dlapiper.com/dlapiperknowledge/globalemploymentlatestdevelopments/2024/latest-changes-to-holiday-pay-and-what-they-mean-for-employers).
The council often points to a two-year limit. That limit applies to what a tribunal can award an individual (https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/holiday-pay-two-year-backdating-limit-claims-submitted-1-july-2015). It does not stop an employer putting right its own mistake.
THE EMPLOYER IS RESPONSIBLE
As we understand the law, the duty to pay holiday pay correctly sits with the employer, the London Borough of Barnet. A council can pay a contractor to run its payroll. In our view it cannot hand over its duty to pay its own staff correctly. If the contractor gets it wrong, the council should pay its staff, then recover the cost from the contractor.
THE CONTRACT GAVE THE COUNCIL THE TOOLS
The council’s 2013 contract with Capita is public (https://open.barnet.gov.uk/download/23d3v/tmb/v24___Barnet_NSCSO___Model_Contract_Body___Final_unredacted_version_20131016.pdf). In our reading, it required Capita to:
- comply with all legislation at all times (clause 4.2.1(d))
- warn the council of anything that would harm the service, including what Capita “should have known” (clause 4.2.1(f))
- fix its own failures at no extra cost to the council (clause 4.2.2)
- bear the cost of routine changes in the law (clause 14)
In 2018 the council itself listed the remedies open to it, including deductions from Capita’s payments, remedy notices and step-in (see question 48, page 30: https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/documents/b31355/Item%205%20-%20Public%20Questions%20and%20Responses%2022nd-Nov-2018%2019.00%20Audit%20Committee.pdf?T=9). It issued remedy notices to Capita after the 2018 fraud. We have found no record that it used them over payroll.
THE COUNCIL WAS WARNED ABOUT PAYROLL, REPEATEDLY
- March 2018: An internal audit rated payroll Limited Assurance. It found faults in overtime controls first reported a year earlier and said 7 of 12 payroll controls were not covered by written policies. The report went to the Chief Executive (https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s47447/Internal%20Audit%20-%20Key%20Financial%20Controls%20-%20Payroll%20non%20schools%20-%20March%202018.pdf).
- February 2019: Schools payroll, also run by Capita, was rated No Assurance, the lowest rating (https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s52422/Schools%20Payroll%20-%20February%202019.pdf).
- July 2019: The council’s head of internal audit gave a Limited Assurance opinion for the second year, citing “particular concerns” about HR, including payroll. The council brought strategic HR back in-house, but left payroll with Capita for six more years (Audit Committee papers, July 2019: https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/ieListMeetings.aspx?CommitteeId=144).
- 2017 to 2025: Capita’s payroll accuracy target of 99.9% was missed in 2017/18 and 2018/19 (https://open.barnet.gov.uk/download/23d3v/dzf/Schedule%201%20Human%20Resources_Redacted.pdf). It was still being missed in some months in the contract’s last two years (https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s86460/Cabinet%20Report%20Capita%20contract%20review.pdf and https://barnet.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s91449/Cabinet%20Report%20Capita%20contract%20review.pdf). Yet in November 2024 Cabinet was told underperformance had been “addressed through robust contract management controls”.
These reports do not spell out the overtime problem. They do show the council knew about serious payroll weaknesses for years. Throughout that time, holiday pay on overtime was never put right while Capita ran payroll.
AN INDEPENDENT REVIEW FOUND WEAK COUNCIL OVERSIGHT
In 2018, after a Capita employee was jailed for a £2 million fraud against the council (https://feeds.bbci.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-45641513), the council commissioned Grant Thornton to investigate (https://www.barnet.gov.uk/your-council/fraud-investigation/financial-controls). The review covered the same contract that ran payroll. It found “insufficient oversight by the Council” and said the council was aware of weaknesses in how it oversaw Capita. It also reported that the council’s target for fixing urgent audit recommendations had not been met since 2013/14. The review was about financial controls, not payroll, but it shows the council knew it was not overseeing Capita properly.
WHAT WE WANT
- The council to pay staff what they are owed, then recover the cost from Capita.
- An independent investigation into how this went on for over ten years.
This article is Barnet UNISON’s reading of public documents, not legal advice. If anything is wrong, tell us and we will correct it.
